THE AWAKE @ 59E59
"Andy Phelan's Malcolm is one of the most striking performances I've seen this year; the tiniest shift in emotion registers on his face in seismic fashion, revealing sorrows that he can barely name"
-David Barbour, Light & Sound America
HONOR AND THE RIVER @ Luna Stage, NJ
"performed without a false step by a superb cast. Eliot is played with heartbreaking vulnerability by Andy Phelan."
- Naomi Siegel, The New York Times
"If "Honor and the River" were to move from Montclair to Manhattan, Andy Phelan just might become a much-awarded theatrical star. He's that exceptional in Anton Dudley's solid new play at Luna Stage Company. Phelan is the main reason why it's the sleeper hit of the season...Even though the playwright carefully envisioned his show, he couldn't have imagined that someone as perfect as Andy Phelan would play Eliot."
- Peter Filichia, The Star Ledger
"Andy Phelan anchors the entire play magnificently by totally inhabiting Eliot."
- Bob Rendell, Talkin' Broadway
For MILKMILKLEMONADE @ Under St. Marks
"Phelan is absolutely extraordinary throughout"
- Elisabeth Vincentelli, New York Post
"The cast is exquisite. Andy Phelan is immensely likeable as Emory"
- Martin Denton, NY Theatre.com
THE BEARD OF AVON @ The Cape Playhouse, MA
"Andy Phelan shines as a transvestite ingenue."
- Sandy MacDonald, The Boston Globe
"The nine actors were brilliant...Andy Phelan had the delightfully challenging roles of Dunderbread and Lady Lettice."
- Libby Hughes, Cape Cod Today
LILA @ Mill Mountain Theatre, VA
"The cast is excellent. Andy Phelan as young Nat has a gift for bringing the audience into his confidence and winning them over. This is essential for the play to work."
- Anna Wentworth, Roanoke.com